A case for learning to drive a manual car in 2024

Learning how to drive on a manual car is still the option of choice in 2024 in Ireland. While the numbers are declining every year, it is estimated that 75% of all driving tests conducted by RSA will still be on a manual car, with younger students still preferring/being advised to learn on a manual car.

In a world dominated by automatic transmissions, the manual car stands as a testament to the joy of driving. Though modern vehicles offer advanced technology and convenience, there's something uniquely satisfying about driving a stick shift. But is learning to drive a manual car in 2024 still worth it? Let's explore the pros and cons of owning and driving a manual transmission vehicle.

Pros of Driving a Manual Car

1. Enhanced Driving Experience

Driving a manual car can be a more engaging and rewarding experience. The need to shift gears manually connects the driver more intimately with the vehicle. You feel every shift and become more attuned to the car's performance.

2. Better Control

Manual transmissions provide better control over the vehicle. In challenging driving conditions, being able to manually select gears can help maintain traction and stability.

3. Fuel Efficiency

Traditionally, manual cars have been more fuel-efficient than their automatic counterparts. Though modern automatics have closed the gap, manuals still tend to offer better mileage in many cases because they are lighter and have less complex machinery.

4. Lower Purchase and Maintenance Costs

Manual cars often cost less upfront compared to automatics. Maintenance can also be cheaper since manual transmissions have simpler mechanics and are less prone to the same kinds of failures that automatic transmissions might experience.

5. Navigating Narrow Roads

Ireland is known for its picturesque but often narrow and winding roads, especially in rural areas. Driving a manual car gives you better control and precision when navigating these challenging routes. The ability to downshift for better engine braking and control can make driving through Ireland's countryside safer and more enjoyable.

Cons of Driving a Manual Car

1. Learning Curve

Learning to drive a manual car can be daunting. It requires coordination and practice to master the clutch and gear shift. New drivers might find this challenging, especially if they are accustomed to the simplicity of automatics.

2. Traffic Hassles

In heavy traffic, driving a manual can become tiresome. Constantly shifting gears and using the clutch in stop-and-go situations can be exhausting and lead to faster wear and tear on the vehicle.

3. Availability and Choice

The market for manual cars is shrinking. Manufacturers are producing fewer models with manual transmissions, making it harder to find and purchase a new manual car. This also limits the variety and choice available to consumers.

4. Resale Value

The resale value of manual cars can be lower because of the decreasing number of people who prefer or can drive them. As automatics become the standard, the demand for manuals might continue to diminish.

5. Convenience

For many, driving an automatic is simply more convenient. Automatics allow drivers to focus more on the road and less on shifting gears, which can be particularly beneficial in urban environments or for long-distance travel.

Learning to Drive a Manual Car

Despite the cons, learning to drive a manual car in 2024 has its merits. It teaches valuable driving skills that can make you a more attentive and capable driver. Here’s why it might still be worth it:

- Skill Development: Learning to drive a manual car enhances your driving abilities. It forces you to be more aware of your surroundings and more deliberate in your actions.

- Versatility: Knowing how to drive a manual car means you can drive virtually any vehicle. This can be a useful skill, especially if you travel abroad or need to drive different types of cars for work or personal reasons.

- Sense of Achievement: Mastering a manual transmission provides a sense of accomplishment and confidence. It’s a skill that not everyone possesses and can set you apart from other drivers.

Conclusion

Owning and driving a manual car in 2024 presents a balanced mix of pros and cons. While the engaging driving experience, better control, and cost benefits are significant advantages, the learning curve, traffic hassles, and decreasing availability are notable drawbacks. Ultimately, the decision to drive a manual car comes down to personal preference and the value you place on the driving experience.

For those willing to embrace the challenge, driving a manual car can be a rewarding and enjoyable endeavor. It offers a connection to the vehicle and the road that is unmatched by automatics. Whether you're a driving enthusiast or just someone looking to enhance your driving skills, the manual transmission still has a place on today’s roads.

So, if you're up for it, why not give it a try? You might just find that the joy of driving a manual car is worth the effort.